The US economy is either right at the edge of falling into another recession or has already entered a second recession. The big money spenders say we need more stimulus. It is kind of like having a drink when you have a terrible hangover (the tail of the dog that bit you).
Is the US economy at a tipping point or has it already tipped over? The best one can possibly say is the economy is at a stall rate.
Harvard University economics professor Martin Feldstein said the U.S. recovery that began two years ago has been losing steam and there are even odds the economy will slip into a recession.
“This economy is really balanced on the edge,” Feldstein said in an interview on Bloomberg Television “Surveillance Midday” with Tom Keene. “I think there’s now a 50 percent chance that we could slide into a new recession.”
What has got us here at the worst recession since the great depression (there are many who believe that we are in a depression). I believe it has been the loose credit cycle of the last 40 years or so with government and the consumer.
Obama certainly didn’t start it but he has put the spending on steroids.
No Solution?
There is a solution, just not a politically viable one. It’s called debt deflation. That is the economy’s way of purging the excesses of a housing bubble and debt orgy.
Instead, the Fed and the ECB-protected bondholders at the expense of taxpayers even though the unemployment rate is sky-high.
The Fed’s action was supposed to get credit flowing again and create jobs. Instead, Fed policy created jobs in China while bailing out US bankers and wealthy bondholders, many of whom arguably belong in prison or stripped of their financial assets.
In the end, Greece defaulted anyway at huge extra cost to European taxpayers. In the US, unemployment rate is 9.2% not counting millions of people who involuntarily dropped out of the labor force.
This is a solution that would in the long run make us an economically viable country. Unfortunately, I don’t think there is the political appetite for this.
But it may happen forcefully at some point in the future whether we like it or not
Keynesians Argue for More Stimulus
Sadly, Keynesians still argue for more stimulus. Supposedly we need to build infrastructure.
Let me ask a question: Where would the US economy be had we done that?
The answer is certainly in a better position than the alternative of dropping bombs in Iraq. For starters the US would have better bridges instead of holes in the Iraq desert and millions of destroyed lives (and millions more enemies on top of that).
However, the US economy would still be where it is now. Why? Because of the three cardinal rules of stimulus.
Three Cardinal Rules of Stimulus
- First rule of stimulus: It always runs out.
- Second rule of stimulus: All it can do is create a greater pile of debt.
- Third rule of stimulus: Spend enough money and interest on debt will eventually consume you.
I thought the first Obama stimulus package was sold to us as “shovel ready jobs” many of which were infrastructure improvements.
I guess those didn’t get done the first time, maybe it will the second time
Never do the Keynesians want to throw in the towel on what they suggest. One might think that the 20-year history of failed infrastructure stimulus in Japan would be enough to open the myopic eyes of Keynesians but one would be wrong.
US Structural Problems
Before we go throwing money around, why not fix a few internal structural problems to ensure we at least get our money’s worth. How do we do that? Easy.
- Scrap Davis Bacon and all prevailing wage laws.
- End collective bargaining of public unions
- Enact national right-to-work legislation
Give me those measures and I will gladly hike taxes a bit. Those measures would at least help ensure we got our money’s worth for government work.
Those would never pass our current congress because they would be seen as anti-union measures. This administration is financially supported by unions.
However, those three items, while desperately needed, do not solve the problem of why jobs are fleeing the US in the first place.
For starters we need corporate tax laws that do not reward and encourage job and capital flight. Second and more importantly, we need to address the issue of trade imbalances
Finally, some of the real reasons that jobs are fleeing the US instead of the usual nonsense talk of the “greedy” business people. Politicians need to stop creating caricatures to campaign against and quite waging class warfare and start addressing the real world problems that are affecting business.
Before wasting more money on stimulus measures doomed to fail, how about fixing internal and external structural problems first? If we do that, and stop the war mongering, we will not even need stimulus; the economy will heal itself.
The economy is life a human body, it has the capacity to heal itself without outside interference.
The problem is that the economy has been artificially manipulated by all levels of government is the name of creating more prosperity. This manipulation has created imbalances that have created financial uncertainly and volatility.
Left to its own devices, our economy would probably already be recovering with strength not what we have. Yes, there would be winners and losers, that is the way of nature. Our politicians can’t let that happen, because they don’t see it as “fair”.
If politicians had their way with nature, there would have never been an evolution in nature, they would have legislated against it because it wasn’t “fair” to the species that eventually were extinct.
We need to let our economy “evolve” into the next stage of our development.